A·S·R  Adjudicated Settlement Record · Worked examples · Questions

How to check a claim against a contract: questions answered on real cases

The same rules decide every claim the ASR reads, whether it is a construction payment, a letter of credit or a prediction-market settlement. Each answer below states the rule and shows it on a real case, with what the ASR found and what was decided later.

How do you verify a payment claim against a contract?How do you check whether evidence satisfies a contract’s conditions?How do you check documents presented under a letter of credit?A document or step is missing, or the contract is silent. Is the claim rejected?What if official records point different ways?Can a clarification added later change what the contract required?What if someone relies on a condition the contract does not contain?How do you record why a claim was paid or refused?How do you check that a settlement record is genuine?

How do you verify a payment claim against a contract?

Read the contract first and list the conditions the claim must meet. Then check each condition on its own, against the evidence the contract names, using only what was known when the claim was made. Each condition gets its own finding: Met, Not shown, Not met, or Contract unclear.

Placefirst: does this pay less notice meet the contract and the Act?Meets. The court later held both notices valid.Lapp: no payment notice and no pay less noticeMeets; the notified sum follows. The court later held the sum payable.

How do you check whether evidence satisfies a contract’s conditions?

Each condition is matched to the clause it comes from and to the evidence the contract says will prove it. Where the contract names the source but not the proof it must give, that source’s own account stands, and the bar is that source, no higher.

Strategy bitcoin sale: the company’s own filingMeets: the named source dates the sale inside the window.Zelenskyy suit: credible reporting as the judgeMeets: the reporting the contract names called it a suit.

How do you check documents presented under a letter of credit?

Each condition of the credit is checked against the documents as presented, before the bank responds. Where the documents themselves show a condition failed, the finding is Not met: it is not treated as a gap in the evidence. Standards the credit refers to but does not supply, such as UCP 600, are flagged for confirmation against the actual text.

Fortis: a certificate that misstates who paysDoes not meet. The court later held the certificate discrepant.

A document or step is missing, or the contract is silent. Is the claim rejected?

No. Missing evidence is a hold with a request for the evidence, not a rejection. Where the terms are silent, the ASR does not add a rule of its own: it holds the point and refers it to a person.

Fortis: how soon must refused documents be returned?Held. The court later implied a “reasonable promptness” rule that the article does not state; the ASR did not add it.

What if official records point different ways?

The ASR does not settle a conflict between records the contract accepts. It says what each record shows and refers the point to a person.

US–Ukraine minerals dealNot shown: records conflict, referred. The market’s vote went Yes.

Can a clarification added later change what the contract required?

No. The claim is assessed on the terms and evidence as they stood when it was made. Notes, statements and rulings issued afterwards are listed separately and not used in the finding.

Strategy bitcoin sale: a note added the day after expiryThe added requirement is outside the terms assessed.Michigan v Western Michigan: rulings after the resultMeets on the final result; three later rulings set aside.

What if someone relies on a condition the contract does not contain?

It is recorded as outside the terms assessed. The ASR checks the conditions the contract states and adds none, so the record shows exactly which term a different result would have needed.

TikTok ban: no duration or enforcement testMeets, review required. The vote also went Yes.Zelenskyy suit: no tailoring definitionMeets. The vote went No.

How do you record why a claim was paid or refused?

The settlement record states each condition against its exact clause, the finding and its reasoning, an evidence register of who produced each item and when, the gaps and what would close them, and a flag wherever a person should review. The claim is read three separate times and the agreement between the readings is stated; the same submission returns the same stored record; the methodology version is stated. The record supports the decision; it is not the decision to pay.

Western Michigan: settled at 0:00 during a reviewNo finding: the readings did not agree, so a person decides. Kalshi later reversed the payout.TikTok ban: two of three readings agreedThe finding is issued and flagged for review.

How do you check that a settlement record is genuine?

Each record is signed. Anyone holding the record file can check on the ASR site that it was issued by the ASR and has not been altered. The file is checked, not stored.

Check a recordUpload the record file (JSON).

Check your own claimWhat the ASR found, and what was decided later